ok get yer cogitating gear around this
"proof" that Zion is also a Matrix. cast your minds back to Reloaded. what was the one overriding plot theme? Trinity's apparent death. This is predicted in the very first scene and is repeated throughout the film, until finally the event becomes actual, and the Artichoke presents this to Neo as the choice he has to make. clearly this has long been pre-determined, the Artichoke is well prepared. but a paradox is presented to us! Trinity's "death" is contingent upon a chain of events that occur outside the Matrix and over which the Artichoke supposedely has no control.
A bolt shears on a gangway on a human ship, purely by accident. this eventually leads to the destruction of said ship and the death of all on board, including those currently plugged into the Matrix. This means potential disaster for Neo, Morpheus and the Keymaker and everything they hope to achieve, unless Trinity enters the Matrix against Neo's warning at the risk of her life. do u see what I'm driving at? if the sheared bolt is truly an accident, then there is no predetermination and how can the Artichoke, The Oracle and Neo know what's going to happen? obv they aren't magic, or psychic; A & O aren't even human, they're programs and weigh probabilities, make intuitive leaps based upon those probabiities, but ultimately like all programs rely on data. how can they assimilate data that hasn't happened and is beyond their control, if it's just an accident? The theme of causality, cause and effect, is hammered home in Reloaded, indeed the Merovingian's speech is about nothing else.
(edit for clarity: Neo as we are shown has only limited sight at this stage, so he only sees what he percieves to be Trin's death. this is a point the Oracle clarifies him on. however we are given pointers that she is ultimatlely doomed, the most obvious being Persephone telling her that such a love is not fated to last. is this just jealousy on P's part? no i dont think so, she has already made it clear that she just wants to remember what emotions and memories a passionate embrace can bring. if she's just another program why would she want to do this? she ain't no prog, or at least wasn't once, she's human! and so is the Merovingian. in case anyone hasn't got it yet, M is a previous One, P is a previous Trinity, over the years since they had their turn, they've been in hiding in the Matrix along with lots of other old programs.)
Therefore as I see it the logical conclusion is that the "real" world of Zion operates under the same conditions as the Matrix itself, meaning that it must be a similar construct, for there is no other way that makes sense to me for these events to be "predictable" The accident was always going to happen, for it was no accident, and sparks off a chain of events that leads Neo to the choice he HAS to make and has already been laid out for him. the world of Zion is as much an illusion as the Matrix itself. What do u reckon?
Edited by - Tawakalna on 17-11-2003 15:43:26
Edited by - Tawakalna on 17-11-2003 20:18:05