Thu Nov 18, 2004 2:26 pm by Triyun
*Begin Rant*
All right, this is really really getting on my nerves. It seems like the Rheinlanders are trying to win on technicality after technicality after technicality. I've been in fleet based RPG's many of them successful for months over the span of several years, and one of the things that made them successful is people tried to make RPing realistic instead of trying to exploit and undermine the every loophole possible. Telling a faction that they are out of character when they do what they need to in order to continue to exist is lacks any common sense. Having Samura defect from their native house is even further out of character. 1 Corporations are in the business of money making not conquest, second its employees probably wouldn't go along. Just because you guys can doesn''t mean you should.
Next, AC seems to be intent on making amendments to treaties and agreeing to them in the same post. He seems to try and dictate to us that a truce (which only halts hostilities, not ends a war) is a permanent peace treaty that prohibits countries from aiding allies. He signs a treaty agreeing not to go into Kusari or Corsair Space, and invades Honshu in the same post. You think that it makes sense for all the houses to pile on the weakest one and support the strongest, but you ignore the lessons of history. Bretonia especially would have probably inheritted Britain's long tradition of always supporting the under dog and never allowing one dominant nation to reign over all others except for itself. This has been true of it until it burned itself out fighting WWII. Liberty descends from the United States which has a strong tradition of respecting national soviergnty. IT would not look kindly on an outside power basically saying one nation could not regulate commerce in its own borders. Both would not look kindly on a House arming a corporation with warships. Capital ships are not defensive weapons, fighters protect convoys well enough against pirates. Capital ships have only one purpose, to use as mobile military bases, and since a corporations nature is to make money, these could easily be used to force domination of space ways. It would be a very very bad thing for their economies. Undoubtedly you'll retort well the blood dragon move was worse. No it wasn't, as I've gone through before, the Japanese are extremely nationalistic and whatever their problems, they'd hate outsiders more. Second, Samura having capital ships would be awful for them also, no one had probably done more piracy on them, then the Blood Dragons. After Kusari fell, they'd be next on the target list, and since the Samura would have a House Level military but none of the defensive positions they'd need to maintain.
Finally this whole retreating thing is complete crap. A battleship is an extremely slow moving ship not to mention its turning speed, there is no way it would be able to escape fast moving fighters. In a battle, no fleet would let the other get away unscratched if they had the advantage in the battle. If this is allowed, it basically gives smaller factions no chance. Your success in the RPG is determined by what faction you get at the beginning rather than how well you play the game if this stands, is basically what your saying. The implications of this would of course be disasterous not to mention it could get very ugly. I've been in RPG's were defeat was just considered something that happen, but I've also been in ones that have gotten highly vicious and mean, and the only reason those that didn't quit didn't was to show their enemy that they were better. This would not be a fun environment at all, and I encourage you to take action to prevent this.
*end rant*