@DTX:
What part of critique do you not understand? If you've read my other critiques here, you'll see that I am fair, gentle on obvious newbies, and I'm not out to diss people "just because".
For example, I critiqued MACE_166's work the same way I would anybody else's, even though I know that his primary strength is as a coder, not as an artist. I know his mod will be great even if the ships aren't 100%... but if he's going to submit it for comments and critique, then I have to judge the art by its merits, because that's what this thread's about. And while it's OK, and it's a great idea, it's not supurb art.
At any rate, my commentary is meant to help artists get better, not just to make them feel bad. When I said, "go read my Tutorial"... I told you that not because I'm a sarcastic cuss, but because you obviously aren't getting a lot've fundamental concepts yet, and I thought that if you read through the tutorial, studied the DemoShip that's included in the initial download, etc... you might progress beyond the "makes neat models but can't execute the rest of it" stage.
Ever since I've encountered you... you've struck me as a brilliant, arrogant... and LAZY person. Quit being lazy... and finish ONE DECENT PIECE... and I will cut you some slack, I promise.
But every time I read your ridiculous tagline: "i can only say im good, nothing more..." I just chuckle... because you're apparantly "too good" to actually get anything nice completed. As somebody who's made (at last count) well over 100 things for the FL game engine, I'm allowed to poke you with whatever sharp sticks I have sitting around, k? Making models for games involves the whole process, not just making something and rendering it with a raytracer... so get over it, do the work, and submit it if you can take the heat.
While I'm ranting and raving at you... your latest model's neat, except for the obvious welding issues all over the geometry. I humbly suggest splitting the facets out and unwelding them before joining them into Groups before preparing the skin. Otherwise, it looks very much of the same style as the original game, and the design has a lot've flair to it- if you can get it skinned, or find somebody else to do it, it'll look very nice when it's complete.
See? I'm not an ogre... just straight-up. Get over it