you can kill something that is one your 6
everything else than a level 10 ship stand no chance against a level 10 ship ... (though ok maybe against a titan, cause its really really sluggish)
so that leaves us the sabre and the eagle as vaild pvp ships
the eagle is more agil, and fires at the screen cornerns aswell with its turret.
energy is no concern.
and a single good salvo can kill your enemy (doesn´t matter if its a eagle, a titan or sabre)
so this leaves the only one thing that matters in combat open.
can I get in shooting position or not.
with a eagle there is NOTHING against you can not get in shooting position.
against a titan, you can play just with one hand, its so sluggish that he will be lucky if he see what killed him.
against a sabre, well, you can still smoke your cig without worry about, you can aswell engage without bots or bats left, cause your enemy will have you that rarely on his screen that your shild reg is mor than enough to compensate for those few hits (and you are always in abit better shooting position, which means you are relativ save from his torps, while your free to shoot yours in his face)
only against an other eagle its a fair match, everything else stand simple no chance, cause the turn rate DOES MATTER in a dogfight.
the game is in pvp more or less exactly what this totaly stupid pro-mouse argument said it would be not -> fyling circles, and the eagle is the best ship in this area ... it flys simple best circles, at least from those ships with a decend armor/shild and weapon rating
To sumurize this long and worthless post, you can´t kill what you can´t hit.
Agility > a little bit more armor
the more agil fighter wins always in a dogfight against the less agil fighter, as long as hit has enough firepower to kill its enemy in a reasonable amount of time.