I should start with the worst game
Probably Superman on the N64...Worst graphics of any game on the 64...One of the missions is you flying through rings...You'd think that Superman would've perfected the art of flight before attempting to save the world...'Nuff said
Gladiator on XBOX...Yuuuccckkk!!! In short, its a game where you play as a Gladiator in ancient Rome...fun huh...But its in the style of a turn based RPG...hmmm
Best Game
Hmmm...Freelancer is definitely the game that has kept me tuning in the longest. Partially because the open-endedness (though it only is actually your choice of what to do after you beat the game) and partially because of the mods, not to mention the months I've spent with my team/friends making a mod.
I also loved Devil May Cry on the PS:2. Gotta love the slice and dice games. Also, infinite ammo with all guns...Always a plus.
Metal Gear Solid is definitely up there. Truly a great game
Not all about the graphics like Splinter Cell (not to say that MGS lacked good graphics or that Splinter Cell is all about graphics)
Biggest surprise,
Simpsons: Hit and Run...one of the worst ideas for a game ever, but surprisingly fun and addictive
Biggest Dissapointment,
Devil May Cry 2, saw those previews....Running up walls.....whooooa!! Can say this, good fighting system, on a terrible game. And the monsters look like they came straight out of a coloring book.