Whats the prize?
How long should voting run for? (current polls can be voted in multiple times, so to put any stock into it would require some better method than is currently available - otherwise I could vote all day long for whatever I chose to
).
Should we run around their websites to alert their communities?
To be honest, Methinks you'll find it would be...
TNG
TNG
TNG
TNG
TNG
They've had the most consistent amount of players online, with the largest amount of downloads too. I think at one very brief point in history, we had more servers and more players with Evo... but it was very short lived - like a week or two (we had about 40 servers at one point, and 130 odd players online).
However, email Finalday or Mental and see what they think - they may work out how to implement it, or whether to take it further.