i.m.o for me its all about interdependency - ship classes evolve out of necessity, not fantasy - each becomes dependent on the others to defend its weak spots, and when a class loses its utility it becomes a throwback and is discontinued
a single ship pit against another of any house in the same class,should stand a 50/50 chance under the condition that it's not the first time the pilot/captain has battled
speculating now; generally ships should have a 50/50 advantage against other classes - where half of the classes will singly or in numbers lose against it,and the other half will likewise be able to defeat it.
example based on the evolution of WWII:
* Battleships: At first, the most important ship around until submarines could sneak past them and even destroy them
* Dreadnoughts: Actually this just means a bigger battleship
* Destroyers: Lightly armored,emphasizing speed and defensive capabilities against torpedo boat and air attack to protect the battleships
* U-boat/Submarines: Highly specialized strategic weapons, they could operate effectively alone and in large wolf packs but were vulnerable to battleships and later cruisers and air patrols
* Aircraft Carriers: Projected air power forward threatening every class of ship, but were large poorly armored targets for counter air strikes, naval bombardment and torpedo attacks.
* Torpedo Boats: Small speedy boats which were nearly impossible to hit with large guns, these were a deadly threat to battleships and even carriers, creating the destroyer class
* Cruisers: Cruisers are a general purpose war ship with no strong advantages,carrying well balanced loadouts that allow it to operate independently,and while lighter classes of cruisers are more vulnerable they can typically outrun what they can't outfight.
for some _highly_ detailed arguments about ship classes and armaments and .. Everything you ever wanted to know about space travel and war in scifi future-history
Space War Introduction *note this is not video game but sci-fi & fact based, and some real scientific thought has gone into this site's extensive pages
Edited by - Cold_Void on 1/25/2006 7:42:18 PM